• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to B-Balls Meatballs

At B-Balls Meatballs, we celebrate the art of meatballs and subs, crafting deliciousness with every bite. Located in Suffern, NY, our story began with a passion for flavorful, hearty dishes inspired by loved recipes. Our menu dazzles with a variety of options, from the famed 'Buckwild Balls' sandwich to tempting appetizers like garlic bread and jalapeño poppers. We've built a community-focused eatery where customer connections matter; our owner, known for her friendly demeanor, ensures every visit is memorable. With homemade Italian ices as the perfect finale, B-Balls Meatballs invites you to savor comfort and joy in every meal.

B-Balls Meatballs: Reviews & Ratings

Cindi
Cindi

So amazing! The meatball subs are so delicious and the service is beyond great. I got the 'whole package' meatball sub and was blown away with the flavor and how every bite was the perfect amount of each ingredient. The owner is a true delight! She was fast and friendly. She over heard my talking about how I wanted disco fries but only a few, so I wasn't going to order a whole side as it would be wasted. To my surprise she prepared me a small portion of disco fries and brought it to where I was eating. Get the lemon Italian ice!!! This is my new go to spot when in the area.

Angela Pegarella
Angela Pegarella

Who knew there could be so many ways to spice up a meatball sub! When I first moved to the area, a local recommended this place. I was intrigued by all the interesting options on the menu and had to try. Although I want to try everything, I love my usual order so much that I haven’t been able to stray. My go to is the Buckwild Balls Sandwich, which I highly recommend. Sometimes the bread is a little burnt, but otherwise cooked to perfection. I will continue going back and maybe one day I’ll feel adventurous enough to stray from my usual!

Christine Aaron
Christine Aaron

The subs here are A. The amount of choices are overwhelming to say the least but it’s great because there is a choice for any mood you’re in. The girl at the counter was so sweet and easy to talk to while we waited for our food. We can’t wait to come back.

Scott Powers
Scott Powers

Old school pizza and sub shop. My daughter and I had an eggplant parm sub and I had an Italian. We also had garlic knots, which were out of this world. The pepperoni pizza looked so good we had to get a couple of slices too. We had to bring food back to the hotel (we were visiting from out of town) but everything was awesome. Very friendly family owner made the visit even nicer.

Amy Arensberg
Amy Arensberg

This place was great! There are so many amazing options it was hard to choose. We started with fried pickles, then we shared the meatball Parm on a "garlic bread" hero and a cheese steak. The meatballs were perfect and, even though cheese steak isn't their specialty, it was delicious as well. Even though we couldn't finish everything, we had to try the Italian ices that Lance, the owner, makes himself. He was very personable and made our experience eating there even better. We'll definitely be back and try some other varieties of the awesomely named sandwiches!

Jennifer Jackson
Jennifer Jackson

Google Maps describes this location as a "Pizza Restaurant", they're hiding the lead. This is a Meatball Sub Paradise where the balls have been seamlessly applied to bountiful buns and well sauced. We ordered 3 different Meatball sandwiches. Here are their names, their descriptions from B-Balls website, and what we thought. #16. Balls To The Wall Sandwich: Meatball sandwich with our own sauce add cheese to make it cheesy then add hot & sweet sausage, cheese, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, layered with mozzarella cheese topped with bacon, pepperoni & ham. My husband ordered this on the garlic hero bread, and it's not to be missed. Don't be swayed by the "Sweaty balls" or "The Whole Package"; trust us, you Need to have "Balls to the Walls" to be really fulfilled. #21 Stick Balls: Meatballs layered on a skewer with bread & mozzarella rolled in bread crumbs and fried. The balance of bread:cheese:ball ratio was perfect. The sauce added just enough moistness to the stick to help it go down easy. Highly recommend this, you won't be disappointed by the experience! #18: Buck Wild Balls: Meatballs layered with chili, bacon, and cheddar cheese topped with steak fries. We ordered this with the bread bowl* on the side. The chili was spicier than my tongue was prepared for, but it was the good kind of burn. The straps of bacon and steak fries helped soothe the sting, but if you can't handle the heat... well, you know. Large Greek Salad: Tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, olives, and feta cheese. The Salad came with house dressing lightly coating the whole tossed salad. It was a nice light bite to eat with the heavy balls. *I ate my salad in the Bread bowl and it was delicious. (The bread bowl has sesame seeds encrusted into it.) The price for every Sub is 12.99, excellent value for a tasty time! Grab your napkins these balls can get messy! Ps: they have no customer restrooms on site, but they do seem to be more takeout than eat in, so most customers wouldn't be affected. Pps: they support their Veterans, both with a collection location for a veteran organization, as well as they gave us a military discount on our whole meal.

Rosemary Brennan
Rosemary Brennan

Friendly atmosphere, good prices and wide selection of what to eat. Also in a residential area .Great corner deli that kids are safe to walk to.They just put Cheesecake on their menu sooo good.Update 2/14 went there and picked up a pizza and went to a friend's house .Food is always delicious and Kelly the owner is such a great lady .very friendly atmosphere and not only a great place to eat it is a throwback from days gone by your neighborhood feel and a small business that is so good to it' s neighborhood.

Andrew Patrick Reynolds
Andrew Patrick Reynolds

Well where can I start? We had just seen Paul McCartney the night before and were looking for a great place for lunch and thanks to Local Guides we found it. Meatballs, Meatballs! So many choices of sandwiches with totally unique recipes but that's not all. They offer pizza, salad and more. I went with a Meatball pizza and a salad. I will never forget how good it tasted. The owners were the best and talked to me at length. I will drive from Connecticut just to eat there.

Location

Welcome to B-Balls Meatballs, a delightful gem nestled in Suffern, NY, at 28 Prairie Ave. This vibrant eatery isn't just another sub shop; it offers a unique twist on the classic meatball sub in a warm, inviting atmosphere.

At B-Balls Meatballs, the menu bursts with creativity. The crown jewel? The Busted Ball Sandwiches. Each option combines rich flavors with quality ingredients. Whether you crave the Hernia Sandwich, layered with cheese, chili, onion, scrambled egg, and served on a hero or round bread bowl for just $12.99, or the Buddy Love Sandwich featuring ratatouille and Monterey Jack cheese, there's a sandwich to satisfy every palate.

  • Hernia Sandwich: Meatballs, cheese, chili, onion, scrambled egg. An explosion of flavors! ($12.99)
  • Stick Balls Sandwich: Meatballs on a skewer, breadcrumb-coated mozzarella. A fun bite-sized delight! ($12.99)
  • Buddy Love Sandwich: Meatballs with ratatouille and Monterey Jack on hero or bread bowl. ($12.99)
  • Regular Crust Pizza: Classic dough base with tomato sauce and cheese, available in personal or regular sizes. Starting at $2.99!

The gratitude shown by owner Lance, who personally engages with customers, elevates the experience. Patrons rave about the friendly service that makes them feel at home. As one reviewer noted, "the service is beyond great." A testament to the inviting community vibe of B-Balls Meatballs.

Highlights of the menu include not only creative meatball sandwiches but also delicious sides like fried pickles and garlic knots, which are absolute must-tries. The cut of each meatball is crafted with care, ensuring each bite is packed with flavor. A notable mention goes to the Italian ice, a refreshing treat hand-made by the owner himself, perfect for those hot summer days.

For pizza lovers, their Regular Crust Pizza can satisfy the craving with a classic blend of toppings starting at just $2.99 for a slice—delicious and delightful!

B-Balls Meatballs is a multifaceted dining experience. With a plethora of options, from the distinctive meatball subs to great pizza, it caters to a variety of tastes and cravings. The 5-star customer reviews speak volumes to the quality and joy that awaits at this charming spot. Swing by for a meal that’s not just food, but a culinary experience that will have you returning for more!

For a taste of creative Italian-American comfort food, call +1 845-357-8054 and make your way to B-Balls Meatballs today!